Which Benchmark?
Which of the many benchmarks is the correct one to use? We have the S&P 500, the Dow, 60/40, Aggregate Bonds, QQQ…
At the end of the day, I think there are two primary ways that I see fit to pick the right benchmark. One is that the benchmark be relevant to the investment. In other words, If you are looking at a Value stock strategy, why would you benchmark it to something other than a value index. If you're looking at a broad US stock strategy, I would think the S&P or Total US Market would be the right benchmark, etc. The other way I see to pick the right benchmark is when it comes to your personal risk comfort. If you are not willing to ride out the volatility and drawdowns of the S&P 500, then it may not be the right benchmark for you, maybe some other allocation such as the 60/40 is more appropriate.
Sometimes I struggle with which benchmark to compare a specific strategy to, I often think I should just compare everything to a 60/40 which I think is probably a more common approach by the masses than the S&P. But for strategies with higher return, I tend to think it makes sense to match them to the S&P. Wiggle room here for sure and I am not sure there is a correct answer.
Model Portfolios have been in the reporting deck, and I've been talking about them for a while now, I am super excited about the three Model Portfolios and the returns and associated metrics with them. On the metrics pages for the Model Portfolios, there are comparative benchmarks for both the Russell 1000 and a 60/40 portfolio, same as with the metrics for the individual strategies.
At the end of the day, I think there are two primary ways that I see fit to pick the right benchmark. One is that the benchmark be relevant to the investment. In other words, If you are looking at a Value stock strategy, why would you benchmark it to something other than a value index. If you're looking at a broad US stock strategy, I would think the S&P or Total US Market would be the right benchmark, etc. The other way I see to pick the right benchmark is when it comes to your personal risk comfort. If you are not willing to ride out the volatility and drawdowns of the S&P 500, then it may not be the right benchmark for you, maybe some other allocation such as the 60/40 is more appropriate.
Sometimes I struggle with which benchmark to compare a specific strategy to, I often think I should just compare everything to a 60/40 which I think is probably a more common approach by the masses than the S&P. But for strategies with higher return, I tend to think it makes sense to match them to the S&P. Wiggle room here for sure and I am not sure there is a correct answer.
Model Portfolios have been in the reporting deck, and I've been talking about them for a while now, I am super excited about the three Model Portfolios and the returns and associated metrics with them. On the metrics pages for the Model Portfolios, there are comparative benchmarks for both the Russell 1000 and a 60/40 portfolio, same as with the metrics for the individual strategies.